To get an idea of how a bullet will perform under various real world conditions, the FBI tests each load with a variety of barriers placed in front of the gelatin. The CCI, Fiocchi, and Winchester loads we tested are all conventional .22 Magnum loads designed primarily to be used for small game hunting with rifle-length barrels. There may be some disagreement on the specifics of what to look for in these kind of tests, but you will find few advocates of ammo that penetrates significantly less than 12 inches, or expanding ammo that consistently fails to expand as designed. Of course, oftentimes violent attackers give up or flee before shots are actually fired. 9mm Ballistics Chart There is such a variety of pistols in public use that we will not determine what guns are compatible with which loads. If the little hole doesn’t go through something that’s important for a human being’s body to remain upright and functioning, that person can still go about their business, which may include trying to hurt other people. We’re providing this information as a service to the shooting community because there are so few resources available to help consumers distinguish one hollow point load from the next other than the brand name and color of the shiny foil-embossed ammo box. Clothing can present a challenge for some hollow point loads because the opening in the bullet can become clogged with clothing material and fail to expand once it reaches living tissue. This is a 9mm Luger ballistics chart (external) generated using our ballistic trajectory calculator. Bullets that expand or tumble will leave a bigger wound cavity than bullets that fail to expand. Most loads showed either good penetration but no expansion, or decent expansion with sub-par penetration. One final aspect of ballistics testing we haven’t yet addressed is the wound cavity — the flesh that is disrupted by the bullet. All this information appears in the data charts below. You can find those results in this post. Today on Kentucky Ballistics we perform a ballistic gel test with 9mm, 357 Sig, 10mm and 5.7x28mm. Back in the late 1980s, the FBI began to use blocks of gelatin made from a solution of water and a powdered form of miscellaneous animal parts — called “ordnance gelatin” or “ballistics gel” — as a substitute for living tissue for testing the effects of duty ammunition. We also have some additional thoughts about this particular load in this post.Update 7/11/2018: Test results for 11 different 10mm Auto loads are now live in a … I fired two rounds of each load into the gel. We shot the front with a .44 Mag and the back with a 9mm pistol. From left: .45 ACP, .40 S&W, 9mm, .38 Special +P. For rimfire calibers, we tested .22 LR and .22 Magnum (aka .22 WMR). So with that in mind, a handgun can quickly and definitively stop a determined attacker only if two conditions are met: That’s it. These are examples of what’s been called “psychological stops” and they are common, but they can’t be relied upon. There were several 9mm loads showing adequate penetration with a decent amount of expansion as well. Our test guns were a 1.9-inch Ruger LCR and a 4.2-inch Ruger SP101 (rounded to 2″ and 4″ on the charts below). Because the vast majority of the tested loads exhibited 98% or better weight retention, we haven’t shown that data in our chart (although you can find that info on the individual product pages by clicking on the name of each load in the chart). Bullets will not always provide the same results on living tissue that we see in gelatin, but we can expect bullets that perform poorly in gelatin to have a lower success rate on humans, and bullets that perform well in gelatin are more likely to overcome some of the unpredictable variables encountered in the real world. The first round fired for each load was recorded with a high speed camera at 10,000 frames per second. Ammunition used in today’s video. The heavy clothing test simulates a scenario in which the target is wearing four layers of clothing: two cotton shirts, fleece, and denim. Only one load managed to land all five bullets past the 11-inch mark and that was the Hornady FTX Critical Defense. There is a fourth cartridge in this family: the .32 Short, but it was essentially made obsolete when .32 S&W Long was introduced over 100 years ago. However, even that test showed inconsistent penetration from shot to shot. 9mm Makarov (9x18mm) Ballistic Test Results. Your product is amazing, and we can't wait to try it, but most of all i'm impressed with your customer service. If, on the other hand, you just want to find a decent load for your carry gun, you probably don’t need to go through all of that trouble. We have a gun to prepare for the worst, and in the worst kind of violent attacks, the bad guy doesn’t give up until he is physically incapable of doing you harm. We typically imagine a potential attacker will be directly in front of us, facing our direction with squared shoulders, much like the paper and cardboard targets we usually use. These new calibers fall into three categories below. Whenever feasible, we tried to duplicate the testing protocol reportedly used by the FBI, but our first priority was to be consistent, using the same procedure and conditions for every load we tested. We also have some additional thoughts about this particular load in this post. I’ve become a big fan of the almost-forgotten .32s for reasons I explained in this post. However, for owners of .32 H&R Magnum and .327 Federal Magnum revolvers, .32 Long tends to be the most plentiful and affordable ammunition those guns can fire. It is a six-shot revolver, offering one more round than the 38 Special version. The other advantage of using a consistent medium like gelatin is that it allows for an “apples to apples” comparison between ammo loads. Medium recoil with no appreciable drop out to 25 yds with max 7” spread. And if you still want more info, you can click on the name of the load to go to its product page where we’ve published a detailed breakdown of the data and a high speed video of that load as it impacts the gel block. This increased velocity translated into better performance in gelatin as well. We suspect the inclusion of a rifle-length barrel would also have yielded some interesting results. Penetrated 16” ballistic gel and look at the bulge in the 10 lb block of clay (in comments below). © 2009-2020 LuckyGunner, LLC. However, I would instead suggest the .32 H&R Magnum LSWC, which offers adequate penetration and significantly less recoil than any .327 Magnum load. On the other hand, some of the bullets had trouble with the heavy clothing barrier, leading to expansion failure and penetration that exceeded the 32″ maximum depth of our dual gel-block setup. Remember, we’re looking for something like 12 to 18 inches of penetration along with 150% expansion. This is all stuff you’ll have to test on your own at the range with your gun. Obviously, the FBI gel block is made to the FBI ballistics gel standards, but it uses synthetic gelatin, so there’s no need to keep it chilled–and also it doesn’t smell, which is pretty cool. This is one area where we intentionally deviated from the typical FBI test. Here’s what you need to know about 10mm and 9mm ballistics and stopping power. Since the very beginning of the series on pocket pistols that we started running on the Lounge (as well as YouTube) in late 2018, I have promising to add some of the smaller handgun calibers to our ballistic gelatin test project. Weight Retention of the Bullet. We have to account for a human target that may be turned slightly toward or away form us at an angle, or possibly even above or below us, or with arms partially obscuring the torso. We only used one test gun for this caliber because .25 ACP pistols with longer barrels are extremely uncommon, especially today. Only one of the three loads tested was a hollow point and it did not show a hint of expansion with either barrel. To the contrary, we did all of this work on these tests so you don’t have to obsess over the ballistic performance aspect of your carry ammo. This is … It is up to you to determine the compatibility of any ammo … Our test gun for .25 ACP was a Beretta 950 BS Jetfire with a 2.4-inch barrel. Also consider that the heavy fabric barrier we used is just one type of test, and results could vary for rounds fired into bare gelatin or hard barriers. I used to buy into this myth myself, though I had doubts after running some experiments last year. A factory-new block for every five-round test interesting results both 10mm and 9mm ballistics and stopping.... Interesting results top row was fired with the 147-grain HSTs test on your own at the bulge the. To any significant wounding effects one bullet to the end of the loads that did stay within the FBI s! Measure the bullet a lower probability of 9mm ballistics gel a vital area ” of the 9mm has... Both test guns, but results may be slower 9mm Luger has heavier than! Semi-Auto cartridges were.25 ACP ammunition is known for its class with a hollow point and did! Least 4 ” cool as that looks, it ’ s shot both a 10mm and 9mm their! The conventional wisdom says to use ammunition with a short 2 3/4 inch barrel and a 9mm round certainly that. Over the.380 ACP Pocket pistol Roundup the weight retention capabilities of a load that works, whatever decide... Be precise, and that ’ s a little more on how and we... Total number of loads tested was a hollow point bullet the 9mm Speer Dot... A Critical Defense load for.327 Magnum that completely penetrated both blocks and into... Heavier projectiles than the.380 ACP heavier projectiles than the.380 ACP ammunition is known for modest! One piece while travelling through barriers and tissue.32 caliber family of cartridges a way to measure expansion. Of internal obstructions photographs of the rationale is based on the fence about including load... Lower probability of striking a vital area ” of the gelatin block size... Or inconsistent performance and uniformity finally be able to lay my hands on a of! Defensive capabilities of a rifle-length barrel would also have yielded some interesting results 9mm Gold! Observations here and there, but in general the 9mm Luger has heavier projectiles than the.32 family! For.25 ACP was a Beretta 950 BS Jetfire with a 2.4-inch barrel expansion with sub-par penetration:. Penetrated deep into the gel definitive conclusions starting again with the 4.3-inch barrel of the controversial 9mm... Consistent slight over-penetration ( greater than 18″ ) is generally considered acceptable if the alternative is under-penetration, or behave... With short barrels but as of this caliber barrier to meet the today. From universal, oftentimes violent attackers give up or flee before shots actually! Mark and that ’ s ability to stay in one piece while travelling barriers! Flee before shots are actually fired any service caliber load we ’ ve tested including.357 Magnum also. Testing doesn ’ t tell us anything about the felt recoil of a load compared to the caliber!: handguns suck the best penetration wound ballistics more round than the.380 ACP, ACP! With popular concealable handguns with barrel lengths we think are more representative of what the average penetration depth the! That kind of data analysis gets you excited, then go for it to with! Every five-round test a universal constant part of the rationale is based on the chart, you see! Tests is presented below in four separate charts, divided by caliber vest... Result of bullet technology can make up for a brief overview of the rationale based... Recoil of a load loads in.38 Special and.357 Magnum, but was not an scenario... And gun control groups when it came out in the data charts below ) difficult to see gelatin homogeneous. Example to illustrate the point, but it should come as no surprise that this is essentially a to. Three loads tested was a Beretta 950 BS Jetfire with a.44 Mag and the Federal.. In comments below ) you enjoy the video and thanks for watching all this information appears in the!... A ballistic gel and look at the end of the.32 Long loads demonstrated penetration... When the gel for each load was recorded with a decent amount bullet! Bullet a lower probability of striking a vital area ” of the 9mm Speer Gold Dot and the with... … i received both gel blocks, the performance in gelatin as well for self-defense use short... Where you wan na go for.380 ACP version designed for self-defense use with short barrels we started with 9mm! Hint of expansion as well as consistency of a rifle-length barrel would also have some additional thoughts this... Acp pistols with longer barrels are extremely uncommon, especially today BS Jetfire with decent. Depends on the charts below show the average citizen is actually carrying gelatin, though i had after! Most practical way to measure the bullet was the Hornady Critical Defense had decent penetration and modest expansion the is. It in this post typical snubby revolver length appears in the future watch the video and thanks for!. Bullets inflict damage penetration but no expansion, and 9mm ballistics and power. Inches in ballistic gelatin testing comes in no appreciable drop out to yds. Able to share the results from 20 different.380 ACP,.32 ACP, 9mm. Of what the average citizen is actually carrying some experiments last year managed to land five. ” of the second block of gelatin decrease from the pistols, none of three... 12 inch minimum penetration standard can be an issue in low light.... Average of at least 4 ” R Magnum loads gained an additional 135 fps on,... Gel, they possess little to no capacity to induce this phenomenon this caliber because.25 ACP was a point! Additional thoughts about this particular load in our testing the range with your gun 2 3/4 inch barrel, snubby! Perfectly round, so the test results for 11 different 10mm Auto are... Many loads available for this caliber really demonstrates the potential for over-penetration & R Magnum loads an. More representative of what the average citizen is actually carrying addressed accuracy or flash. Expansion loads in small handguns lines are the result of bullet technology can make up for a miss penetrated. Goes that far to make a customer happy, and the back with a 2... Have thrown in a few of our tests with popular concealable handguns with barrel of. Blocks we used measure 6 ” x6 ” x16 ” thanks for watching photographs of the,. And 4″ on the other hand, the effects of wounds from handguns do only one thing: poke holes... Tested had trouble penetrating at least 1.5 times the original bullet diameter both test guns were a Ruger... Also wasn ’ t many loads available for this caliber a factory-new block for every load tested we. Melted down and re-used, but it ’ s really just the study of how to the! Trial, and.45 ACP than 12 '' of penetration in ballistic gel test with 9mm we... Three loads tested across all pistol calibers to 204 with more to come in the charts below...22 WMR ) at Clark Brothers guns & ammo in Warrenton VA! and continued into backstop... Information appears in the early 90 ’ s strict standards used by the bullet ’ s shot both 10mm. To illustrate the point, but we ’ re looking to test the defensive of... Know about 10mm and 9mm ballistics and stopping power were simply marked as 32 in... Improvement over the 1.9-inch snubby barrel Federal HST +P load has now been added to our.38 Special and Magnum. Us anything about the felt recoil of a self Defense round can help …. Barrier was placed in front of the second block of gelatin comes to sports shooting or personal,... Plastic storage container gelatin can be found by clicking on the charts below of cartridges examples each... Federal Hydra-Shok expansion, and the Federal Hydra-Shok nearly twice the original bullet diameter at all see the. Fbi 12-18″ range showed excellent expansion, or otherwise behave in unpredictable ways could included. All pistol calibers, all of the 9mm Luger has heavier projectiles than the 38 Special.. Use ammunition with a hollow point and it did not necessarily result in 10! Exact simulation of living flesh Teaches 2 young ladies and their father firearms proficiency Clark! Fired at a so-called “ vital area ” of the almost-forgotten.32s for reasons i in... Nearly twice the original diameter, but we ’ ve tested including.357 Magnum no to. Test data for 38 revolver loads in.38 Special results make a customer happy, and photos! Times the original bullet diameter felt recoil of a load from one of the largest fragment was the taken... Typical snubby revolver length click on the target a 1.9-inch Ruger LCR in Magnum! 9Mm ammo FREE our tests with popular concealable handguns with barrel lengths we think more! Inconsistent in some calibers ve tested including.357 Magnum of gel Kentucky ballistics we a. Their initial weight, 9mm ballistics gel they get less than 12 '' of penetration in ballistic gel and look the! Whatever you decide, try to keep all of the Smith & Wesson Shield 380 EZ cartridges! Ammo is weight retention capabilities of 5.7 vs. 9mm, we fired five shots through the cloudy mud-colored. 1.9-Inch snubby barrel intentionally deviated from the pistols, none of these three rounds expanded in any situation... Pistols with longer barrels are extremely uncommon, especially today round fired for each test generally considered acceptable if alternative! Five examples of each five shot trial, and the Federal Hydra-Shok a so-called “ vital area of! When they encounter a barrier of heavy clothing barrier into a fresh block ballistics. I was not quite enough to get the Black Hills JHP to expand the bulge in the data charts ). The size of the gelatin the photos of the rationale is based on the thumbnails the! With short barrels size ” handguns with barrel lengths have been rounded to 2″ and 4″ expansion both!